Keyboard GeniusesKeyboard Geniuses is our occasional glance at a few intriguing, witty, or otherwise notable posts from the community’s discussion threads. Comments have been excerpted and edited here for grammar, length, and/or clarity.  

Nostalgia Trigger

Our current Special Topics In Gameology series marched forward this week with Anthony John Agnello examining Chrono Trigger and the bond it builds between players and the heroes’ hometown, Truce. Anthony argues that Crono and his crew—and the player, by proxy—must witness every stage of Truce’s history, from creation to destruction, on their road to saving it. CNightwing compared it to another classic time travel story, where watching a single setting undergo changes from era to era made the journey all the more effective:

This is the right way to do time travel. Going right back to H.G. Wells, what draws people into the narrative is the observation of change in surroundings they have become familiar with. The eponymous Time Machine moves barely a few feet in the entire novel, and each stop on the way to the far future is marked by observation—of what businesses came and went, of what fashions changed, of the passing of each major war. Back To The Future does this too. It’s just as much a story of Hill Valley as it is Marty or Doc Brown, and all the little details that go into showing the audience how much has changed, and yet remained the same, is what makes it all believable, even the cheesiest bit about the janitor becoming mayor.

For comparison, series like Timecop or Sliders (if you allow alternate realities as a similar form of travel) don’t draw you in to their principle storytelling device because things change too much, and there’s barely a connection with the world in which you began. It’s important for a location to be a character in itself—to develop a little over time, to change like any other character would according to what challenges faced them. Quantum Leap managed to do this while moving around constantly by portraying changes across the entire US. That has to be one of the keys to its success, that combination of nostalgia and observations on changing times.

I’d really like to play a game that tries to emulate the changing times that have faced settlements over the ages. It needn’t cover all of time of course but starting with a sleepy medieval village and seeing how it changes with plague, war, famine, and dreaded economics would fascinate me, even if there was no goal, or I risked the town falling to ruin. I like Dwarf Fortress, but it’s not quite what I’m looking for here.

Advertisement

Elsewhere, NakedSnake summed up the motivational power of Chrono Trigger’s time travel:

I came to Chrono Trigger late, which is to say, I played it for the first time last year. When I first started it, I was a little bemused about the powerful nostalgia that people felt about the game. The characters were fun but didn’t grab my attention, and the main plot was almost non-existent. It felt like a series of semi-serious vignettes. As the game wore on, though, I became more and more engrossed. It’s not the characters or their stories that draw you in. It’s the world itself. Each time I saw the world transformed from time period to time period, I understood more about it. You start to see how everything is interconnected, and how the story really is bigger than your merry band of adventurers. Most games that ask you to save the world give little thought to what that world looks like. For Chrono Trigger, saving the world becomes an urgent priority because you feel truly and strongly connected to that particular place.

Plumberduck provided a link to an in-depth analysis of Chrono Trigger’s story, one that examines it as two separate halves that fit into two different classical archetypes. It’s an interesting read. Shinigami Apple Merchant responded with another two-tales-in-one interpretation:

I like to view the game as two interwoven tales as well. The first part is The Tragedy Of Magus—sort of predetermination meets Dickens. He’s determined to never be useful to his people, he’s cast aside by time itself, he fights to save the only one who ever saw inherent value in him (besides his cat), and no matter what he does, he only ends up being an integral part of said tragedy as The Prophet.

The second part is The Hero’s Journey Of Crono. Through his unbridled optimism and altruism, he refuels Frog’s need to live (beyond performing the occasional act of heroism). He is tested time and time again (pun intended), by the defeatism of the future era, the acrimony of the war in the Middle Ages era, being pursued by the King’s guard in his own era, and trying to find some avenue with which to change the flow of time and avert the downfall of everything.

We see the strings and how they’re all connected because one, Magus, was at the epicenter of it all, and the other, Crono, pushes through blindly, only being pushed on by his spirit and connection with his friends. Crono’s fatal sacrifice and the group’s subsequent need to believe that he can be revived becomes the soul of the game’s final arc. Even if the book of history says that it’s over, you can always find a new page with which to change things for the better.

I find it’s the tragedy of Magus combined with the joy of Crono’s success that makes this gameso resonant. You can’t change everything, but if you cherish life, you can’t stop trying to make things better either. Who you do it for and why is what separates the people of Zeal’s kingdom from Crono and his friends.

Advertisement

Mystified

This week also brought the surprising news that Legendary Pictures will be turning Myst, the classic series of exploratory puzzle games, into some sort of TV show. John Teti, probably the biggest Myst lover I know, wondered how a video game as devoid of characters as Myst could make for a TV show. Myst fans, like ItsTheShadsy, presented a few options down in the comments:

There’s a lot they could do with Myst, if you’d believe it. As the series went on, they established a surprisingly deep lore for the series, mostly revolving around the history of the fallen D’ni civilization. This was especially clear in the Uru spinoff, which was more story and mythology-driven compared to previous entries. At its worst, you could find several Silmarillion-esque volumes that were just names of kings. But at its best, the political intrigue of D’ni was tremendous place-setting that gave weight to the rest of the game world. The Myst universe is open-ended by design, so there’s a lot of directions they could go in that would either complement the games or stand independently.

There was actually an attempt at an independent-but-sanctioned Myst movie a few years back, and it was supposed to deal with all the backstory and mythology. That fell apart under terrible mismanagement and in-fighting among the producers.

(Fun insane Myst lore fact: The Uru spinoff takes place in the present day after an archaeological group discovers the remains of the D’ni civilization buried underground in New Mexico. The Myst games exist within the universe of Uru as “documentaries” made about these findings.)

Advertisement

And GreatGreyBeast had some ideas as well:

All kidding aside, the general premise of the games lends itself to a Quantum Leap sort of series—every episode finds the hero(s) in an unfamiliar world where they must unravel some local problem while learning a little about themselves. If that hero is Atrus, serialized hints about the threat of his sons/father could be filled in around the sides. I’m not saying it would be good, but that’s the form I’d expect this to take.

I could also see this as a sprawling fantasy soap opera, a la Once Upon A Time. That would work best either set in the ancient book-writing civilization that provides Myst’s backstory (the most expensive option, as making this work would require a budget to rival Game Of Thrones), or in a modern, URU-like setting, following some improbably attractive explorers getting lost in the ruins, learning about the books, and struggling to preserve/exploit them.

Advertisement

Knowing as little as I do about Myst, I have to say, I was one of those jerks who heard the idea and immediately assumed the show would be some sort of Lost ripoff.

Speaking of ripoffs, thesmokeylife jokingly expressed a preference for a TV show based on Drowned God, a Myst-like game that has the player uncovering the truth behind humanity’s ascendance (an ancient, advanced civilization helped us become what we are—that chestnut). After Mike_From_Chicago posted a link to an old Gamespot review of Drowned God, thesmokeylife returned to share an interview the site did with the game’s creator, an author, forger, and conspiracy theorist going by the name Harry Horse. He claims the game is based on a manuscript about the days following the destruction of Atlantis—a manuscript that he forged himself and attributed to the British poet Richard Horne (who shares Horse’s birth name). Yeah, it’s an odd interview, to say the least.

That’s all for this week. Once again, thank you for reading and commenting. We’ll see you all next week!

Advertisement